Proposal Evaluation Criteria



Proposal flow chart

Proposal flow chart

Evaluation Criteria

Your research paper will be evaluated according to the following criteria:

  • The choice of the topic :
    • Does it match the conference themes and topics ?
    • Is it interesting ?
    • Is it too broad or narrow ?
  • Appropriateness of the form of presentation.
  • Study vs Experience Report.
  • The form of the paper :
    • How does the paper look ?
    • Is the content presented well ?
    • Does form follow function, (i.e. size)
    • Adherence to formatting guidelines
    • Organization into sections
    • Usage of summaries, examples, and conclusions
    • Usage of figures and tables
    • Usage of definitions
    • Usage of references and citations language and style
    • Consistency in presentation
  • Content of the paper
    • Is the work motivated ?
    • Is the reasoning clear and sound ?
    • Are the own ideas sound ?
    • Are the facts and examples correct and appropriate ?
    • Are the definitions and the terminology appropriate ?
    • Are the references and other sources appropriate ?
    • Is something important missing ?
    • How deeply is the topic covered ?
    • Does the paper make a contribution ?
    • Is it plagiarism ?